REVIEWS AGAIN...

ifadeo · Post by **ifadeo** » 21/03/2003 - 15:33

what brillant review:

REVIEW BY JULIEN (21/03/2003)
Does anybody know the original composer of this theme ? I remember having seen something on the web like J.S. Bach but I am not quite sure.

Thanks,

Julien

btw. the tune is also very high rated, but i don't know why julien
rate the to the max......

i'm wondering....

cheers 2Klang

CraigG · Post by **CraigG** » 21/03/2003 - 17:59

Hmmm... I reckon LMan's idea about moderating reviews might have to become a reality at some point.

Post by **tas** » 21/03/2003 - 19:33

seems so, which is a bit disapoiting really as we didn't want to go that way really.

Chris Abbott · Post by **Chris Abbott** » 21/03/2003 - 22:08

> seems so, which is a bit disapoiting really as we didn't want to go
> that way really.
I always thought it was inevitable: when you get the wider public
actually producing content, it's bound to be of ... variable quality, shall
we say.

Chris

Post by **tas** » 22/03/2003 - 9:20

agreed, back in my mind i also thought the same thing, but hopefully this should'nt put people off. We would be able to explain why reviews have been rejected.

Neil

Markus Schneider · Post by **Markus Schneider** » 22/03/2003 - 11:47

IMHO one reason for those very dodgy reviews is this that you can't write as a guest her and you know people are just too lazy registering, when they have other possibilities with beeing registered on R64 voting.

Perhaps a pop up message after clicking 'write a review' with rules like
1.) Don't use this for a messages
2.) Don't refer to other reviews
3.) Don't eat your hamster
4.) ....

would be a good idea ...

Post by **LMan** » 24/03/2003 - 7:34

I am certain that there are only 2 kinds of people on the world:

1. Those who read the guidelines
2. Those who don't

And I'm sure that putting the guidelines above or below the review box, or making it pop up, will not make any difference there

- Markus

CraigG · Post by **CraigG** » 24/03/2003 - 10:05

LMan--sadly, you're right, although putting them above at least makes them more prominent. I think moderation will have to come into effect, although then the moderators will get some stick from people who reckon their words are amazing...

Still, even in its current form, it's good to have the reviews in addition to the previous ratings-only approach.