Makke wrote:I must say, that R64 and RKO voters are probably among the least style biased I've ever come across.
Most people look to the quality of idea, arrangement, and mixing. The style in itself is usually not as important, as long as the quality is high. Of course, there are a few people who'll always downvote a style they don't like (and even so, the style will most often not be the difference between Very Good and Poor), but the majority will most likely give a pretty fair vote. Plus, running around shouting that people vote your tune bad because of the style only makes you yourself look bad.
So I think the R64/RKO voters will give you as fair a judgment as a public vote will allow.
well yeah, i'm also more interested in how the "remix" was made, not in what style it has been made.
but i doubt i made my remix badly.. ok maybe one or more wrong notes, but that's because i didn't knew better.
i always try to be as perfect as possible, so those notes broke my neck there
and i don't want to make me look bad, it's people like these rather making me think i'm bad:
Amiga4eveR shouts: Menisk = tEiS??? ! (voting profile)
just because menisk got me the highest vote. actually menisk even asked for a flac version of the song.
Analog-X64 wrote:You hit the nail on the head.... I couldnt have said it better.
I'm going to use myself as an example. I'm not too crazy about C64 Tunes remixed in the Orchestral Style, but I dont let the style dictate my vote. I can still appreciate the work that has gone into producing such a remix and give it a fair vote, and appropriate comment for the style.
well yes. orchestral remixes would even get my attention abit more as i'm a big orchestral nerd ;D ..
but yea, if the work is done well, all is cool..
i still sense some people downvote ..for whatever reason. nevertheless, i feel comfy with my remix ..
Infamous wrote:Indeed with your human race tune i was personally expecting some kind of electro affair (like the new stuff thats floating about now.. fedde le grande, mason etc) and im pretty sure if it had carried on in that context it'd have come across pretty well as it stands it was a little disjointed but for a 1st effort its good and i think its got a yellow face too which really isnt bad at all (if you truly care about the voting system as a "voting system").
i dont know that style, can you be abit more precisely?
.. nuskool breakz or miami bass ?
electro has a width range sub styles. dave tipper or thomas fehlmann? .. richard d james?
and ye, making house of it. i think i felt doing it because my mate is more a house/techno producer (daXX),
it was atleast for his musicdisk project
Infamous wrote:
I look forward to hearing the D&B tune and if thats your predominent style then dont feel you have to change to suit everyone else if you like writing your music in that style then do that, as makke said this is one place where you dont have to be sociably acceptable musically to be sociably accepted, do what makes you happy and enjoy the advantages given to us for free and generously by lman/don kwed etc.
oh and welcome to the "scene" hehe
well i stopped producing remixes ages ago, i felt not being original doing remixes.
so now after years i started again, my paranoimia (felix schmidt) remix was completly d&b and boy,
alot disliked it .. even though it's very well made.
you can never suite everyone ..
but again, thanks guys .. i'll try to make some more remixes, just need to know some nice c64 songs
as i never have had a c64 myself