generalumber wrote:Seriously mate, I must admit that I was very surprised to be welcomed here like that. This is my first contribution to this place, and I expected people to either
a) say something nice
or
b) say something constructive.
A) I'm sorry if you were offended. That wasn't my intention. However, if you publish something publicly the first lesson you need to learn is that people will criticize your work. If you ask for opinions, you'll get them. But yes, my criticism may have been a bit harsh. I guess it's just because people here generally are more used to straight shooting, but I can see how my post could be seen as offensive. For that I apologize.
B) I'm not sure I can say anything more constructive about your "remix" since I disagree with the entire concept. But since you asked for more detail, I hope you won't be offended by my continued rambling. You're welcome to ignore it if you don't feel there's any truth to it.
If you have designed those sounds yourself, then good job! They're nice sounds, but to me they don't sound any different from the MIDI-sounds of the PC original, which in my opinion makes the remix pointless (kind of like some SID+drums remixes we see on RKO for example). Why would I want to listen to your remix instead of the original? I think, and this is my own personal opinion, a remix should either come from a completely different angle than the original source (i.e. completely different style or sound), or at least give the original source an updated coat. Your remix does neither, in my opinion, and thus I fail to see the point.
As I can see we're in complete and utter disagreement here, and I'm suspecting in a continued debate we'd only end up in a loop of "I'm right, you're wrong"-kind of posts. Which would be pointless since both of us are right, as we're basing our arguments on subjective thinking, i.e. personal taste.
ekl conveniently joined the forum to congratulate you on your excellent remix, and there's your proof that you obviously don't need to please me, as I don't seem to be part of your target audience.
ekl wrote:I'm a fan of pure sounds , micro-harmonics and a funky , driving retro-analog-percussion, as pretty often seen in demos.
And what a wonderful world it is, when different opinions are allowed.
no insult swordfighting here plz ^^
Actually you have been very successfull with 'freshing up' the original. Found your youtube-video by coincidence and your remix was very catchy at once. Great sound assembly.