Listener's Reviews

all c64 only Amiga only

Displaying Reviews 1351 - 1380 out of 2731

Login

Wizardry (Marco Polo Edit) - arranged by Dr Future

Review by LaLa, 12/05/2010

As a fan of Rondo Veneziano, I've instantly recognized their pop-renaissance style in this remix, so I guess that's a good thing.


Unfortunately, where this remix falls flat is in the instrumentation. The winds (flutes, piccolos, etc.) and the strings are especially lacking in sonic detail. And that Korg preset overused by Enigma and others at 1:16 is just too tacky for me. Add it all up and the end result comes out sounding somewhat cheap.


I do like the drums, though, and I do like the arrangement of the remix, it just needs a bit more attention to the instrumentation details.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Navy Moves - arranged by SIDrip Alliance

Review by LaLa, 03/05/2010

Whoa, quite a tour de force! Great job, guys, great job! However, allow me to provide some critique of this great remix.


First of all, whether due to mixing or arrangement, the remix sounds a bit too chaotic. Yes, Navy Moves demands a powerful remix like this, but this may be just a wee bit too much of a good thing. Sounds like everything was mixed in on the same level and thus, there's no separation of the tracks.


Second, that lead kicking in at 1:14 is rather weak. C'mon, a tune like this needs powerful electric guitars for lead, not a wah-wah filtered synth! Either that, or mix it in more to the front and add some more effects to it to make it stand out from the near-chaotic drums and bass.


Third, I know that Navy Moves is looping tune, but the ending of this remix leaves me unsatisfied. If you're interested, drop me an email and I'll tell you what kind of ending do I imagine for this SID. 😊


All in all, definitely the best Navy Moves remix to date, but I'm still awaiting for the ultimate one.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Traveling - arranged by Dekubitussi

Review by NecroPolo, 30/04/2010

C'mon guys, you all have that, so turn on your AGC/masterprocc for this one. I did it and was blown away😊


Please, listen to the boys and learn the dark secrets of mastering. It will improve all things on the long run. You already have the chops, the idea and style. You just need to power up the sound to the level of the other fine elements.


Besides, I'm really glad that someone took the huge challenge of remixing Kjell's excellent music. Have my respect for that!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Zimxusaf I (feat. Mimmo Sanborn) - arranged by N-JOY

Review by chabee, 29/04/2010

Beautifull piano, marvelous sax… It's an excellent cover! I like your style! It remind me Brian Culbertson's music. I'm waiting for your next remix😉
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

They Stole A Million (The Guvnor Mix) - arranged by Martin Dodd

Review by NecroPolo, 08/04/2010

I totally believe in fight with opened helmet approach so I admit if I was wrong😊


With this remix, that is the case.


I mentioned plastic orchestra in the shout before. Well, as it turned out, the instrument that you can hear here is a real trumpet, supported with synth brass. The layer of plastic orchestra totally tricked my ears. But, why is that important - and why is it important to change the comment?


Because real instruments have souls. They require much time, skill, heart, care and attention. Without all of that, they just make noise and don't sing.


I have a full respect of this. It just deserved a more detailed feedback.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Dixie Bits (country punk edition) - arranged by NecroPolo

Review by LaLa, 02/04/2010

We need more of these: medleys of various tunes! We need more of these: fun little remixes in traditional styles! We need more of these: actual guitars instead of synthetic ones!


This remix should be included as a bonus track on a re-release of Reyn's The Blithe, the Blend and the Bizarre - it'd be a perfect fit.


I'd be a bit happier if it was more uptempo, but that's the only complaint I could think of for this piece.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Dixie Bits (country punk edition) - arranged by NecroPolo

Review by chabee, 30/03/2010

Hey man! You are guitar virtuoso! 😊 This is a very great medley! Perfect arranegment and mood! I think, in every sense of the word excellent production.

I'm waiting for next release my friend😉
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Dear Rob V.20 - arranged by D Robinson offline

Review by gibs, 18/03/2010

This tune has been composed by Frederic Hahn (Ackerlight) and is one of the Karsten Obarski's favorite mod.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Commando (feat. Makke) - arranged by Romeo Knight

Review by LaLa, 27/02/2010

This is as close to how I always imagined Commando as it can get! Heavy metal guitars, blistering lead guitar solos, great drumming. Top-notch production.


The mixing seems a bit off, though, the vocals are a bit too soft. And the singer's voice should be more raspy. Yeah, I'm splitting hairs now. 😊


Definitely a keeper!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Basics of Love (feat. Makke) - arranged by moog (Sebastian Bachliñski)

Review by maskkkk, 26/02/2010

Beautiful tune! Quite a contrast from Makke's BITCH! From it's Binary Baby. Heheh ah I like both tunes anyhow.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Future City - arranged by Amok

Review by Ernie76, 19/02/2010

I like it, even if i prefere more speedy sounds with a hard base. ( Maybe theres a chance for another Version ;P ).

All in all the usual good Amok Style.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Speedball 2 Brutal Method - arranged by SNeaR

Review by Erekose, 10/02/2010

Great sound, great guitar, near some metal song except some part of the drums, but it hard to find good synth drums.

I wasn't big fan of the original one but you change it well!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Magic Afternoon (instrumental) - arranged by Ic3m4n

Review by Galaldir, 06/02/2010

I have to admit it, this is the first time ever that I hear *any* version of Magic afternoon.


It all started some month ago when looking for vintage computer game related music (originals and remixes as well) for playing them at Retro Games eV. In Karlsruhe, Germany. A good friend of mine just brought an extra CD… and this very version of Magic Afternoon was there. At first I just ignored the (for me) unknown title. It was after some weekends that it accidentally got live while I was attending some customers…


… that was amazing! Some people stopped playing at the arcade machines and pinballs just for asking what the name of the tune was, or for some that were more savvy than me, for asking which interpreter did that version of Magic Afternoon


Huh? Dunno…


This interpretation just fixed my attention making me getting curious for hearing at the original version, and after doing so I was more that thrilled when realizing how amazingly well this remix version was

planed and performed.


Beautiful


Praise:
  • It respects the essence of the original. The most important point for me.

  • It's spacy (is this the correct term?), I love that.

  • The tune is clean and consistent, well balanced, but… (see below)

  • The selection of instruments is almost flawless.

  • Introduces some subtle improvements and variances compared to the original.

  • The drums are just perfect


Critic:
  • The lead Xilophone/Arpeggiator is a little bit shrill and loud, specially at the higher pitches.

  • The lead Synth could be a little less… hmmm… acid?

  • Bass and Base-Pad (Specially the bass) could be a little bit more present, but maybe this is just due to the dominating lead Xilo and Synth.


All in all. One of my all time favorites in my retro music collection.


I give it the best note.


And thank to the interpreter for sharing!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Baboon (Skydive ReMix) - arranged by Chabee

Review by NecroPolo, 04/02/2010

Chabee vs DRAX? Awesomeness! 😃


This remix could both capture the mellow atmosphere of the fine original and added so much to it. For me it feels like adding subtle, elegant and style-correct details and finishing an already nice painting.


Man, I must admit that this is my fav remix from you - and my fav remix in 2010, so far.


Keep releasing fine pieces like this one!


Gratuálok Maestro, eddig nálam visz mindent ebben az évben! 😊
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Iron Lord - arranged by moog (Sebastian Bachliñski)

Review by LaLa, 01/02/2010

Well, the style of the remix is hardly a stretch since Iron Lord itself is a cover of the famous renaissance song 'Pase el agua'. Except here it's rendered in baroque. Ish.


Some of the instruments are a bit too sterile sounding, and I miss the vocals that make this remix pale in comparison to some live renditions. Still, a valiant effort and rather enjoyable.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Knucklebusters (PSX Music2000 edit) - arranged by Tomsk

Review by Windshield_CB, 30/01/2010

Don't let the comments fool you - finding a Knucklebusters remix too long is like finding a Grateful Dead cover band too jammy; such a complaint completely misses the point of the original. This is by far the best remix yet of this challenging song, and the only version which even comes close to the original's crunchy, aggro bass.

While the truth in labelling here is no more than a happy accident, it's a very, very happy accident indeed - this remix takes the C64 original and forces it through the sonic sensibilities of the musical schizoid men of the 21st century. Like the 21st century itself, it's a little too sterile in places (I really dislike the patch used for the majority of the main theme (~3:00 - ~8:00) - sounds far too MIDI; and the original's sliding, squealing, distorted bass at the nine-minute mark has been reduced to staccaco keyboards). The rhythm section for the final solos is so good that it almost compells one to forgive the slightly under-polished, late-stage Beta release that is the majority of the final solo itself.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Arkanoid - Techhouse RMX - arranged by daXX offline

Review by Instant Remedy, 17/01/2010

I can just say WOW!

The production values and technical skills are top notch. The beat is really catchy and thumpin'. Cool effects and stuff to go with the beat. Structure is actually pretty interesting and keeps you listeing to see whats next. Only downside with these kind of remixes is that the closer you get to a *real* dancefloor remix the further you get from the original. DaXX went all the way to get this to the floor and it succeeded with highest marks. DaXX fattest remix to date (and I've probably heard them all).
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Boogie Factor 2 - arranged by Chabee

Review by LaLa, 13/01/2010

What a catchy little tune! I caught myself whistling it this morning.


I really like the happy chillout style of the remix, I especially like how all the arpeggios have been carefully converted to chords. The bass is a tad weak to my ears, in fact, the entire remix has a slight squeakiness to it. I also wish it used the stereo space better, it sounds too mono.


However, those are small gripes - this is a real gem and a joy to listen to!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Silent Service II Title Remix - arranged by CZ Tunes

Review by neglesaks, 12/01/2010

(review updated July/2017): This is one of the best Amiga remixes in a long time. This one packs a punch with a solid bass presence ad a clearly marked tempo/beat line. There is a *very* nice use of sonar pings as part of the arrangement which hammers home the felling that this takes place not just at sea, this is outright naval action! The choice of instruments works very well and as an added sprinkling of goodies, it has some samples from a well known motion picture in the same alley as this game. All in all, this is a very good remix that really hits home the feeling of naval maneuvers and wargames. Well done CZ!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Maniac Mansion Theme (feat. Mitch van Hayden) - arranged by Amok

Review by Ernie76, 05/01/2010

This is just how i like Remixes. The new Tunes, added to the song fit Perfect. The Drums are just like i wannted to hear in this song back in c64 days. And last but not Least for a Retro guy like me, the mixed in Sid sounds from the Original.

Great Work
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Cybernoid II (80's-Style-Edit) - arranged by C64toBit64

Review by LaLa, 04/01/2010

I understand the brave decision to re-work the entire melody line of Cybernoid to make it sound more 80's - but for crying out loud, the original is already a great melody in the 80's style, so why the re-write? Unfortunately, I just can't get over this re-write, even though all the 80's sounds and cliches are in there.


Up until 1:24 I had high hopes, but from that point on it's just doesn't sound very pleasing to my ears. Plus there is little variation in there, so in the end this 6+ minute remix is just plain boring.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Be There (Caribian Dreams) - arranged by Chabee

Review by LaLa, 04/01/2010

This remix reminds me of the 90's electronic music with some Jan Hammer thrown in there. I really like the intro! The bass could be stronger and the bell-like backing a little softer, but overall it's a great piece of work.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Commando (Sound of SceneSat Edit) - arranged by Firestorm

Review by Xorcerer, 22/12/2009

Hubbard's tunes are probably the most popular and recognized in the 8-bit community. This guy has really set an all-time high standard for gametunes. And he constantly pushed the audio coding up to it's limits, creating new effects which others mimicked and based upon.

This is why it is very hard to catch up to his brilliant spirit (even though hard technology is now far beyond dreams of the past). It is also very hard NOT to loose this spirit in flood of new technical tricks.

Simplicity, power, pride - this is what it takes to take Hubbard's tunes beyond original blipping 3-channels.

This Commando rmx is even better than IK+, to me both are just filled with the right energy up to the limits.

There might be a little better synth orchestra - but still this qualifies for the best remix of 2009.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Commando (Sound of SceneSat Edit) - arranged by Firestorm

Review by Ryrynz, 20/12/2009

Wow.. It's beat Rastan as the greatest track of all time on RKO.. quite a feat.


What an amazing tune to listen to, very much reminds me of the Unreal Tournament tracks.


Firestorm, you have created a track which sounds so amazingly professional it really is no wonder it's hit number one.


I very much look forward to similar remixes from you in future.. Well done.


There needs to be a new smiley made for this track.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

InCompleeto - arranged by Vincenzo

Review by LaLa, 18/12/2009

Hmm, well, not exactly the style I expected for this wacky SID, but it sorta works. Great intro, interesting Hammond lead, I kinda like the improvisational midpart jamming (where it steers away from the original), horribly abrupt change to edginess towards the end, way too abrupt ending, and that's what really brought down my rating for this remix.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Shades (in the rain) - arranged by Mordi

Review by LaLa, 17/12/2009

Where can I buy this mordifier plugin? It sounds awesome.😉


What an epic! Although the main theme is based on Shades, I also hear a lot of Green Beret and Hysteria in there, all masterfully and convincingly slipped into the remix.


This is such an ethereal and hauntingly beautiful piece of music… It's very enjoyable. The arrangement, the sound quality, the mastering - nothing to complain about here.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Commando (Sound of SceneSat Edit) - arranged by Firestorm

Review by LaLa, 17/12/2009

Wow. This is quite a tour de force!


In style it reminds me of Jesper Kyd's and Richard Jacques' symphonic-electronic game soundtracks, and it's absolutely brilliant at that. It has a great variety of moods all interwoven so that it actually tells a story.


So, the arrangement is simply brilliant, but it also brings a very professional sounding virtual orchestra to the table coupled with some well-placed electronic sounds and drums.


I really look forward to hearing this remix as-is performed by a real orchestra at a game music festival!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Maniac Mansion Theme (feat. Mitch van Hayden) - arranged by Amok

Review by skyrunner, 12/12/2009

Great, thats just teh shit. Just the last days I was listening to the other remixes of this tune (of course there are already some good ones but…), wishing there would be a version like this one.


While freaking out, it suddenly was over at 1:30 playtime. wtf? You can't be serious?!

I felt like a child whose lollipop got stolen. ^^

Of course I know the original is only 1:30, too but nevertheless…


So, to show my disappointment its only a grey face at artistry, although its clearly a red one too like the other both categories.


No one with some common sense could really critisize Amoks technical skills. ^^


Although sounding modern (of course) Amok catched all that nostalgic feeling. Will fit that 3d remake perfectly. I'm looking forward to that game too.


Well, please everyone voting sign that petition:

We demand a longplay version!!!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Pooyan (subtune 1) - arranged by Wolk

Review by Anbalsilfer, 19/11/2009

Listen to this mix.

Then listen to the original.

To actually take that crappy over-speeded piece of *#! and turn it into something not only listenable but both wildly amusing and quite catchy is nothing short of masterful! Kudos to Wolk for creating one of my favorite C64 remixes to date.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Great Giana Sisters (PTTM Distortion Remix) - arranged by Sonic Wanderer

Review by Anbalsilfer, 19/11/2009

This remix is so awesome compared to the original it is scary! Its feeling and style fits the original very well, possibly with the exception of the lead theme synth which feels slightly over the edge and out of place. The original song is also somewhat monotonous and bland, which this mix doesn't completely remedy. Still definitely one of the best remixes out there to date.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

1 2 3 ⋅⋅⋅ 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 ⋅⋅⋅ 90 91 92