Listener's Reviews

all c64 only Amiga only

Displaying Reviews 1351 - 1380 out of 2428

Login

Rastan - arranged by Glyn R Brown

Review by mfe, 10/06/2005

Just the choir sample in this was unfortunately cheesy. Everything else in this is about as faultless as it gets. Brilliant sense of orchestration and a wonderful flair for the dramatic makes this a keeper, and fully deserving of the No. 1 position in the ranks.

I would love to hear this piece remastered with a more faithful choir sample. When everything else is so brilliant, it sticks out like a sore thumb, or like a mole would on the Mona Lisa.

Kudos all the way!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Great Giana Sisters - arranged by machinae supremacy

Review by mfe, 10/06/2005

I'll start with the bad: I'm not a rock/metal fan.

That said, I can say that this arrangement smacks of professionalism, a brilliant sense of timing and creativity, mixing skills that rival most if not all commercial outfits and studios, and actually got me nodding my head along to a familiar SID.

Hats off to machinae supremacy…
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Ghouls n Ghosts (The Errant Ghost) - arranged by load_error

Review by mfe, 08/06/2005

I actually like this piece. It blends industrial and electronic in a style that is reminiscent of Jarre's "Miss Moon" and "Rendez-Vous V/VI". The original SID is repetative in nature, and this arrangement reflects that while developing upon the original idea.

I don't mind the lack of any real lead tune; it's an ambient/atmospheric piece to my ear, something perfectly suited to backing a video collage or a piece of arthouse post-modern cinematography.

For the most part it is well constructed, though the percussion balance is inappropriately loud in places. What I feel is missing is a coheseive bass sound to complement the percussion, even if it were something so simple as a pedal drone with the appropriately grungy feeling to it. The breaks in the "melody" are well timed, but the transitions could be better effected to lead from one to the other; as they stand now, they are a little too short, and are more jarring than Jarre-ing (if you'll excuse the pun).

It just misses out of a red from me for the aforementiond reasons, but it's still very much worth the download for me. Kudos!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Giana Sisters (They are punks and they are back) - arranged by X-formZ

Review by romeo_knight, 07/06/2005

Mmmh, I'll try to explain why this is 'only' good for me though I normally love guitar orientated remixes:
1. There's already a far superior version of this sid in almost exactly the same style: Machinae Supremacy
2. I know it's always difficult to program drums that ought to sound like live drums but here it's too obvious, e. g. only 1 crash sound that's repeated over and over sounds awkward.
3. The guitar sound is too grainy and digital. There are ways of getting proper higain sounds without miking tube amps nowadays.
The guitar playing itself is really good and has decent timing.

Alltogether it's a respectable effort, but with Machinae Supremacy in the back just not good enough.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

The Human Race (Melodie Eine) - arranged by Das Karl Werk Projekt

Review by romeo_knight, 06/06/2005

At first I thought: Ok, another one of these mediocre remixed-to-death ones, but I was wrong. This remix is pure electronica without compromise and its arrangement and mixing shows a lot of professionality. The drumbeat deserves its name (beat!) and works perfectly with the rest. With its partly weird but always unique sounds and techno sfx 'The Human Race (Melodie Eine)' seems to feature the opposite mood of the ingenius original (2-voiced!) sid - but it is absolutely true to its origin anyway and original for itself at the same time. The piano end part adds another unsuspected dimension to it. No choice for me: Outstanding job!
The only tiny flaw: The end should have been a sustained chord, not just one wonky choppy note.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Ocean loader 5 (swing mix) - arranged by Kent Walldén

Review by 8_bit_fingers, 03/06/2005

Woah, Slooow Grooov, I like thit one a lot!
I already like the orginal Ocean Sids. So hearing this
"please wait now loading" tune.
is
Exelent
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Tusker - Finale - arranged by FeekZoid

Review by ikonsgr, 30/05/2005

It's pretty amazing that, so many years after Commodore era, a tune, based on the good old sid synthesizer, can create such a magic and mystical atmosphere! You can close your eyes and travel in outerspace! It is something that i never heard before: a superb binding of jungle sounds, sid bass, and modern synth sounds. I especially liked the short bell melody at the ending of the tune. Followed by the short 'rock like' ending made me feel a sweet nostalgia of the legendary pioneers of home computers, C64 and AMIGA the best computers ever made!!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Comic Bakery (feat Hanna Kappelin & Morpheus) - arranged by o2

Review by canuck, 27/05/2005

Okay, while I'm not the one to push forward and tell the world how much I love this or that… here and now I have to make an exception.
To date I thought no arranger could get close to Instant Remedy's mix of Comic Bakery (and please don't misunderstand, IR's mix is still out of this world and I have 'tortured' my wife by playing it at least a million times) but this one catches up and then some.
While I have to disagree with other reviews that this has Jean Michel Jarre written all over it it sure spells K R A F T W E R K. Rightfully so, Kraftwerk have defined electronic music like nobody else after them. Might as well aim at the best. Enough talking, time to rate:
Technically this is a work of beauty, the artistic impression is right on par but I deduct the obligatory point for nostalgic impression because the Acapella approach just doesn't bring those old SID flashbacks to mind.
It's a good thing because I re-learned how uniqe and cool this song actually is because the mix doesn't just COPY, it re-defines…
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Future Shock - arranged by Romeo Knight

Review by LaLa, 23/05/2005

This is very cool! The original SID is a great piece of groovy, funky music and thankfully, this remix stays very true to that spirit. I think the instrument selection is spot on and the arrangement is excellent. Never fails to bring a smile to my face.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Savage (sub 2 from 80ies 2 now) - arranged by Putzi

Review by LaLa, 23/05/2005

Since it is one of my favorite SID tunes, here's a longer review of this tune instead of just a shout.

The opening is kick-ass, the bass is really cool, but most of the lead instruments should've been selected more carefully. They sound tedious and they wear me down. Or they're simply thin and out of place.

Although the remix tries to be in the 80's style, I don't feel a lot of 80's radiating from this one. A better groove would've probably helped there.

All in all, a nice effort, but this tune deserves so much more.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Toy Bizarre - arranged by Chris Prattini

Review by Mecandes, 23/05/2005

A nice take on a great classic game that's always hard to remember how to spell.😉 Thanks again!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Ultima V (The Battle Begins - Time for Peace) - arranged by Chris Prattini

Review by Mecandes, 23/05/2005

Another great one! Your original bit towards the end reminds me of classic Enya… Nice! The Ultima series has so many great tunes just begging to be remixed…
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Bard's Tale II (Subtune 3) - arranged by Chris Prattini offline

Review by Mecandes, 23/05/2005

An absolutely amazing remix. It brings me to tears to hear such an awesome rendition. Please, for the love of all that is holy, create remixes of more Bard's Tale tunes! 😊
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Last Ninja III (qso-mix) - arranged by Cirdan

Review by Tomsk, 19/05/2005

Another tune to pass me by - but I've had plenty of time to hear it over and over, and I happy to report that it hits the spot. Production is nice and choice of instruments good too (except the ahh-choir at the start… which sounds like a tracker sample). Everytime I hear this I picture a movie's opening credits - which I think it would sound great in. Very very good stuff!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Game Over - arranged by Kenz

Review by Tomsk, 19/05/2005

Gosh - this tune must have been out for ages before I finally managed to hear it (on a slay radio show - no less). Yeah I know there's a whole load of the original chucked in there, but it's very well balanced. To be honest, there's nothing I don't like about this - and lots of things I do. The Sid lead sounds fresh - as do all of the drums… and that bass line is superb.
This is one that nearly passed me by, and I can't really remember being a fan of the original, but this is a great little cover. Bang on stuff - and a current fav on my compilation at the moment. A bit of a shame that lovely bass and main theme couldn't have lasted a bit longer - but all in all I really love this.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Bubble Bobble (Live!) - arranged by Hampshire Regional High School

Review by oddball, 17/05/2005

Now that's some funny stuff!

LOL Actually the last minute sounds very close to the AMIGA version…
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Noisy Pillars (Euro-4-Sure Mix) - arranged by Sonic Wanderer

Review by Instant Remedy, 13/05/2005

Whohoo!
I love it when Sonic does this!
When he does his magic mixture of "enhanced" spacedance, eurodisco and trance. Never heard the original but it doesn't matter, I only had to hear this tune once to love it!
Nice, smooth sound and good use of sounds. Cool voice sample too 😊
This is not the first time Sonic inspired me to make music, I feel like just going home from work and start making music. Too bad there is no time for that in the nearest future.
Thanks for the music Sonic!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Foreign Girl (Kim Nichols mix) - arranged by Wobbler

Review by omoroca, 12/05/2005

I don't know the original SID, but I love this remix. It produces a really cool atmosphere of nostalgic Science Fiction, like in the movie eXistenZ. But who the f@#$ is Kim Nichols?
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Great Giana Sisters - arranged by machinae supremacy

Review by buzzard, 11/05/2005

Most tracks have a shelf life of around 3 months generally speaking, you listen to it, like it, add to a good few playlists or burn onto several homemade compilation cds etc.
THen, inevitably, you get bored of hearing it and find something new to listen to.
This particular track is now a well over 3 years old and has lost none of the 'wow' factor from when I first heard it!

Not only was this one of the best remixes ever written, it still is as good, if not better than anything else since.

For those who never had a c64 - it's an amazing piece of music.
For those who grew up with a c64, it's a real sweet flashback as well.

The only question that remains now, is what happened to Machinae Supremacy???
Someone needs to kidnap whoever was responsible for this gem and lock them in a recording studio ASAP!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Suicide for 2 Pianos - arranged by Bladiator

Review by franky, 05/05/2005

A great Idea to play this song only with 2 Pianos. It sound like a Oveture to a Piano Concert, do more please.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Delta (Spanish guitar) - arranged by Noviello Pippo

Review by plokolp, 02/05/2005

Man, if I could play guitar half as good as this, I'd be twice as happy! This is good stuff. Good for an Argentine Tango ala Delta.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Furycalypse Now (feat. Tuomio) - arranged by Axeman

Review by plokolp, 02/05/2005

I loved this one. I am not familiar with the original SID, so I gave a neutral on that one. Great guitar work. More importantly, I think this piece of music achieves what all great music should do - it makes you think and reflect on things. With a war theme and samples of the movie, this is a great tune that really got me thinking about the futility of war. This is powerful stuff. The choppers, the gas, the gunfire, the scream when the guy is shot - brilliant. The haunting last words of 'Someday this war is going to end" take this fantastic remix out. Oh, did I mention I really liked the guitar work?
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Sidology Episode 3 - arranged by machinae supremacy

Review by plokolp, 02/05/2005

What a great surprise to hear the Monty on the Run right in the middle of this tune! Hard-rockin stuff. Makes me want to pick up the guitar and jam along. This is fantastic riffin.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Kikstart II (Kik-It Mix) - arranged by Sonic Wanderer

Review by mahadeva, 18/04/2005

Reminds me on good old Astral Projection brainfucking tunes… wonderful! Will try to play it open air this summer. Go on with it, Sonic.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Kikstart II (Kik-It Mix) - arranged by Sonic Wanderer

Review by putzi, 17/04/2005

The intro reminds of the mod-style in the Amiga-AGA demo-days, some goa-trance-alike. Very nice to hear this in Sonic-perfection. The compression sounds a bit like it pumps when you listen for the first time, but later this feeling goes away 😉
Not sounding like the average dance-tune, thats for sure. Playing it again and again. 😊
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Alibi (steady-state remix) - arranged by Patrick [Major Minor] Ceuppens

Review by DJB, 15/04/2005

Man, what can I say, I'm blown away!!

Good arrangement, and perfect instruments, and a flawless conversion of the lead. The lead sound is a perfect nostalgic link back to the original SID version, it reminds me so much of it 😊

10/10 from me, thank you so much for doing this tune!!
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Syncopated (by Laxity) - arranged by Vernest

Review by DJB, 15/04/2005

This tune was one of the first C64 tunes I really loved, however this conversion does disappoint a litle. By all means, it's great that this tune finally got done, bust some of the instruments and leads REALLY need fixing If this is was fully polished up, bad instruments removed, and re-released, it would get a much higher ranking than I give it.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Bruce Lee (Psycho Mix) - arranged by Bart Klepka

Review by puppet_xeno, 07/04/2005

I am not offended by the lack of technical or artistic creativity, as I agree on the drums emphasizing the strength of the original sidtune and the original Bruce Lee (the Dude!) samples to state the nostalgia of this entirety. Overall this mix pleases me, really! yet as an artist I must say more could have been done with extra synths and better, more dynamic and/or more persuasive drum sounds.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

IK+ (Chemical Stadium Remix) - arranged by DHS

Review by puppet_xeno, 06/04/2005

The screaming audience samples make this mix sound so over-the-top it almost becomes ridiculous. But it's a very original approach and it did give me goosebumps at some points, and that's mainly positive. It sounds very lively and because of this it is easily overlooked that the rest of the production isn't VERY innovative and would get a bit boring as it's just a lot of repeating patterns - nevertheless I can really enjoy listening to it. Brings back memories and places them in a different light.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Caverns of Khafka (Thriller mix) - arranged by dor-x

Review by puppet_xeno, 05/04/2005

The acoustic-instrument tracks greatly add to the dreariness of the original tune. Although the percussion sounds are somewhat too dry to my taste, overall this mix summons the same kind of spookyness as the original game.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

1 2 3 ⋅⋅⋅ 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 ⋅⋅⋅ 79 80 81